creatures caves welcome, guest
downloads   gallery   dev   community   creatchi   forum   mycaves
bookmarks | search | post new topic
Strangeo Forum
old
Book   
VioletGrendel

VioletGrendel
Ireland  


  3/12/2015

This is now seriously out of date, and highly embarresing, so I've deleted it.


What is the answer to Life, the Universe, and Everything?

42!

 
Siinamon

Siinamon



  3/25/2015

There are a vast amount of reasons why people may not have given feedback, and they might be less-inclined to do so after your post above.

If you are serious about wanting feedback, have you tried communities that are much better with giving feedback? DeviantART and the NaNoWriMo Forums (which are open all year) are pretty invaluable for myself, when I need feedback.

 
GimmeCat

GimmeCat



  3/25/2015

There's a lot to critique, but here's a few I picked out in the first quarter or so of the chapter. These aren't the only problems I found, but they're the ones I can elucidate in a constructive manner.

while on the crowns their grew several tall, swaying poplar trees.


^ Possibly a typo, but if not, practice the difference between "there" "their" and "they're"

Alikora, Runnar's sister, and also a ruler of Taylinaj, although she had little or no wish to use magic, so she had no Crystals, although she had finished the magical training that all rulers took.


^ This run-on sentence is tying too many thoughts together, evidenced by the repeating use of 'although'. Break it into several sentences, and consider going into more depth about the details you're mentioning. If they're important enough to be mentioned here, you should elaborate. Else, delete them.

"I did too," Alikora paused, then said "There are three people outside who want to show you something of importance. Do you want to speak to them?" The way she emphasised the word you suggested that they had refused to speak to her, and she was annoyed about it.
"I'll see them." Said Runnar.


^ This section is lacking proper structure. Start a new paragraph for every speaker. The words in bold are unnecessary and can be deleted to improve the flow. Instead of the tell-y, rambling sentence about the girl sounding annoyed, try something simpler. Show how she seems annoyed, don't just tell the reader "she was annoyed".

Amongst the bustle of his castle, a small group stood out, in that they waited expectantly, and did nothing, save hold the heads of their horses. Runnar stepped towards them, and their heads swivelled to look at him.


^ This was both confusing and funny to read, because it sounds like the group is literally holding the severed heads of their horses, which then swivel of their own accord to face Runnar as he approaches. :D

The woman had vanished from his sight, but Runnar hardly registered this


^ If he didn't register it, don't mention it in the middle of a fight scene. Mention it when she suddenly reappears. Here, you are reminding the reader of her strange absence from the scene, ruining your own surprise reveal later.

Swiping his sword down, he sliced at the snout of one of the werewolves, for that was what they were.


^ Don't tell me what they are, describe them. Ideally, wait for a character to introduce the word "werewolf" in dialog before using it in your narration.

The vampire snarled at Runnar to shut up.


^ Falling squarely under the golden "show, don't tell" rule of storytelling, she should either snarl at Runnar, or tell him to "Shut up" with actual dialog, or both. Especially when you then immediately follow with dialog repeating this exact action.

She smiled silkily


^ Adverbs are evil. Dump it and describe exactly what "silkily" is supposed to look like. If you can't describe what a "silky smile" looks like to the reader, don't expect them to know what it looks like, either.

grinning in triumph again.
She lifted them triumphantly above her head.


(and other actions performed 'triumphantly')
^ Again: show, don't tell. Get rid of any instances of the adverb "triumphantly".

Runnar said wonderingly.


^ This is completely nonsensical to me. DUMP THE ADVERBS! :) Also, never repeat an action like this. If the character says "What's this?" you don't need to follow it with 'he wondered' or similar. It has already been made obvious that he's wondering something.

-------

I'd continue, but this is unfortunately all I have time for. I will say that I noticed a couple of patterns developing, that probably continue to exist all the way through the text. So, based on the above examples, my top tips for improvement are:

1) Dump all adverbs. No survivors!
2) Show, don't tell!

These two simple rules will really force you to paint a truer picture for the reader. Describe body language. Make dialog meaningful, in the sense that every word choice is showing me this character's biases, suspicions, and mannerisms. Adverbs allow you to fly through scenes at lightspeed, not giving them enough time to have any visual impact.

This story, as far as I made through it, was a hurried sequence of scenes lacking in flavour and detail. The characters felt shallow; not because they are, necessarily, but because I was being told their emotions, instead of seeing them for myself. They felt like actors, instead of real people acting and reacting to events. It should never be necessary to tell the reader what a character is thinking or feeling-- it should be evident from their body language and dialog.

My suspension of disbelief was disturbed early on, when Runnar basically just followed an unknown group of strangers into the forest, without any questions asked. Does this seem like something a believable person would do? The impression I got from that scene was: he's either an extremely naive idiot, or it was just a poorly written scene. But the biggest problem is, I couldn't tell which.

That's all I got. I'm not the best writer myself, but I've shared what I can. Keep writing-- improvement comes with practice, and lots of it! :)

 
VioletGrendel

VioletGrendel



  3/28/2015

Thanks GimmeCat. I've never been very good at characters [nblush]. That is, making them appear they way I want them to. Oh, and that their was just a typo.
I've started rewriting it based on what you said, and I think I'll make his part a prologue rather than the first chapter. It doesn't really flow on the way the others do.
You're right about that horses bit. I never noticed that before, but made me laugh too when you pointed it out!


What is the answer to Life, the Universe, and Everything?

42!

 
GimmeCat

GimmeCat



  3/28/2015

Awesome! I'm really glad to hear you're taking another look at it. Giving honest critique is always a bit worrying. Nobody wants to discourage a writer from writing, but some people have tough time seperating themselves from their work. Having something you're currently proud of be picked apart by a stranger can be quite demotivating!

I hope that as you read back over the chapter, you'll see many ways in which it can be improved-- the end result being something you can feel even more proud of than before!

 
Dienes

Dienes



  7/9/2015  1

Have you tried out Edit Minion? I think you'd find it really helpful for a first draft.
 


downloads
cobs
adoptions
creaturelink
metarooms
breeds
 
gallery
art
wallpaper
screenshots
graphics
promos
sprites
dev
hack shack
script reservations
dev resources
active projects
dev forum
 
community
links
advice
chat
polls
resources
creatchi
 
forum
bookmarks
general
news
help
development
strangeo
survivor
mycaves
log in
register
lost pw
0 online
creatures caves is your #1 resource for the creatures artificial life game series: creatures, creatures 2, creatures 3, docking station, and the upcoming creatures family.

contact    help    privacy policy    terms & conditions    rules    donate    wiki