creatures caves welcome, guest
downloads   gallery   dev   community   creatchi   forum   mycaves
bookmarks | search | post new topic
General Forum
old
Are creatures programs?   
scoota94

scoota94
United Kingdom  


  1/11/2010

After a heated debate with my older brother I am going to do what I always do when I need to let of steam..... Complain! :P The definition for program in computer terms is "instructions for a computer to execute". Would you say that creatures are programs?

Don't be worried about who is right, Just follow you heart...
 
sam999

sam999


 visit sam999's website: Speculative Evolution
  1/11/2010

Norns, ettins and grendels are not as they can make their own choices about their lives. Gaia however, as she has a set perpose is.
 
AquaShee

AquaShee



  1/11/2010

Technically, Norns are indeed a set of instructions to be carried out. But in modern times this doesn't qualify them as a program as we know it. They're more like parts of the game, which is a complex program. Otherwise things like a piece of cheese in C3 would be a program too.

Computers have become so complex that what we now see as programs are in fact hundreds of programs working together on different layers. Calling a Norn a program would thus be a bit silly unless you get really old-fashioned or nit-picky.

Whether or not they make their own choices does not change whether they are a program or not, Sam999. Every action a Norn takes is based on the current contents of its memory, environment and perhaps a number thrown out by a pseudo-random number generator. If you put in the same data, the same result comes out. Always. No exceptions. So Norns cannot take choices. They will choose what they were designed to to choose. Programmed.


The Community Scribble: make (y)our own metaroom!
 
Zesvotzashni

Zesvotzashni



  1/12/2010

Aquashee wrote:
They will choose what they were designed to to choose. Programmed



It's really creepy if you think about it, cause we are, to an extent, quite programmed ourselves, it's just one program is infinitely more complicated than the other.

 
scoota94

scoota94



  1/12/2010

^ I agree! We are slightly "programmed" from birth to carry out instructions (like breeding to continue our species)

Don't be worried about who is right, Just follow you heart...
 
ratkinzluver33

ratkinzluver33



  1/14/2010

Lol my norns have some sort of program ERROR! lol! They seem 2 hate all neko ettins XD

~Ratty <3
 
Moe

Moe


 visit Moe's website: Creatures 2 to Docking Station
  1/15/2010

Has anyone tried a set of experiments where you open a world, watch the norn's actions, close without saving, reopen, rinse wash and repeat and see if they do indeed choose the same thing to do each time?
 
AquaShee

AquaShee



  1/16/2010

You can notice it immediately when using the mini-copier, Moe. The two twin norns will do the exact same thing for a few seconds until they either try to pick up the same object, or an element of randomness separates their attention spans.

Basic computer science tells us the Norns will indeed do the very same things in both repetitions of the same world, but only if the random values are identical. And since the random values are based on the computer clock, they won't. They'll be fooled for a few seconds, though, just like the mini-copier does.


The Community Scribble: make (y)our own metaroom!
 
Moe

Moe


 visit Moe's website: Creatures 2 to Docking Station
  1/16/2010

That's what I was wondering. The "computer clock" and the random variables. At least it gives the illusion of autonomy. :)
 
AquaShee

AquaShee



  1/16/2010

They're still autonomous. Just because they make the same decision each time you run the world doesn't mean they didn't choose it themselves.

A choice you make is always based on your past experiences, the current situation, your current mood and your personality. So if all these things are exactly the same, you'd make the exact same choice again. Of course, it's almost impossible to have this happen in the real world, since time only moves forward so every situation is new.

Same for Norns, but simpler.


The Community Scribble: make (y)our own metaroom!
 
scoota94

scoota94



  1/16/2010

Ok how about we all agree on one of these statements:

1-Creatures are programs
2-Creatures ,to an extent, are programs
3-Creatures are not programs

Which one do you agree with?
:)


Don't be worried about who is right, Just follow you heart...
 
Moe

Moe


 visit Moe's website: Creatures 2 to Docking Station
  1/16/2010

To AquaShee:

That may be true, but there is the possibility- I believe it lies someplace in quantum theory -that randomness (actually, pseudo-randomness) exists in our universe much as it does in the Creatures engine, and I suppose it's possible we could be affected by minute "randomly spun" variations in the fabric of our universe as well. This is all assuming no spiritual component of course.

Whatever the case, I understand what you're saying. :)

 
Malkin

Malkin

Manager


 visit Malkin's website: Malkin's page at CWiki
  1/16/2010

The Trousers of Time, Moe? ;)

My TCR Norns
 


downloads
cobs
adoptions
creaturelink
metarooms
breeds
 
gallery
art
wallpaper
screenshots
graphics
promos
sprites
dev
hack shack
script reservations
dev resources
active projects
dev forum
 
community
links
advice
chat
polls
resources
creatchi
 
forum
bookmarks
general
news
help
development
strangeo
survivor
mycaves
log in
register
lost pw
0 online
creatures caves is your #1 resource for the creatures artificial life game series: creatures, creatures 2, creatures 3, docking station, and the upcoming creatures family.

contact    help    privacy policy    terms & conditions    rules    donate    wiki